| Citizens
proposes massive insurance increases - Businesses face 600% rises;
home policies could double Coastal South Florida commercial
property owners could get hit with massive property insurance price
increases up to 603 percent in Broward County and 592 percent in
Palm Beach County, while some homeowners along the coast could see
their premiums more than double, under rate increases proposed Thursday
by state-backed Citizens Property Insurance Corp.
The increases are a "stake through the heart" for the
state economy and homeowners alike, said House Democratic Leader
Dan Gelber of Miami Beach.
The startling increases for home and condominium owners would enable
Citizens, Florida's largest property insurer, to comply with a new
state law forcing the company to set rates high enough to cover
losses from a major catastrophic storm without relying on all Floridians
to bail out the state insurer.
The increases will be phased in over three years, starting in March,
if approved by state insurance regulators. Citizens' board of governors
will vote on the proposed price increases at its December 7 meeting
in Gainesville. Should the board approve them, the rate adjustment
request will be reviewed by the state Office of Insurance Regulation.
The large increases proposed for commercial property owners have
nothing to do with the law legislators passed in May at the end
of the 2006 session, Citizens spokesman Rocky Scott said. Citizens
decided to bring its commercial rates in line with premiums charged
by a new state pool that provides commercial insurance to business
and property owners that can't get coverage from a private insurer,
he said.
Small business owners in South Florida already are feeling the
pain of higher insurance premiums, with many forced to pay substantially
higher rents because property owners are paying much more to insure
their buildings.
Even though Citizens' planned commercial insurance increases aren't
tied to the new insurance legislation, lawmakers "knew this
was going to be the result of the bill, yet Republicans voted for
it and Gov. Bush signed it into law," Gelber said.
And if Citizens substantially increases its rates, Gelber said
private insurers will continue to do the same.
"Citizens ... creates almost an upward draft for rates across
the state," Gelber said. "I think you can probably expect
the private market to follow suit."
But state Rep. Dennis Ross, chairman of the House Insurance Committee
and one of the architects of the insurance bill passed this year,
said the law never was meant to make Citizens' rates affordable.
The law is intended to ensure that Citizens had the financial ability
to stand on its own, without relying on extra charges paid by Florida
property insurance policyholders, said Ross, R-Lakeland.
As the state's insurer of last resort, Citizens must have higher
rates than private companies, "unless the people of the state
of Florida want the state to be an insurance company," Ross
said. "The rates for Citizens are not going to be a question
of affordability."
Citizens' business and homeowner customers could start being charged
the higher prices starting in March, Scott said. But some home and
condo owners wouldn't see the increases at one time.
Home and condo customers whose policies renew between January 1
and May 1 would see their rates go up by as much as 40 percent in
Broward and 30 percent in Palm Beach County, with the rest of the
increase -- averaging 55.8 percent -- coming when they renew in
2008, Scott said.
Customers whose policies renew after May 1 would see the entire
increase at once, he said.
Regulators can't reject the proposed rates simply because of their
size, said Bob Lotane, an insurance department spokesman. "If
these rates prove to be actuarially sound under the new law we would
have no legal basis to deny them," Lotane said.
|